From Policy to Perceptions: A Multilevel Study of Diversity Approaches and Perceived Inclusive Climate

Project info

Work package
  • Work
Sustainability threat
  • External Shocks
Challenge
  • Reshaping organizational forms

Study info

Description of Study
Inclusive workplace climates are central to translating employee diversity into positive outcomes, yet questions remain about how organizational diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) policies can foster such climates. Drawing on the diversity approaches paradigm, signaling theory, identity safety theory, and the intended–actual–experienced framework, this research examined whether an identity-conscious approach, in addition to identity-blind approaches, is associated with employees’ perceptions of an inclusive climate, and whether these associations differ by minority status. Using data from the Netherlands Inclusivity Monitor, we linked HR-reported policies with survey responses from 20,205 employees across 51 organizations, thereby capturing diversity approaches at both the organization-policy and employee-perception levels. Multilevel analyses showed that identity-conscious policies were significantly, though modestly, associated with perceptions of an inclusive climate. Importantly, employees’ own perceptions of identity-consciousness were strongly related to perceived inclusive climate for both majority and minority employees, with somewhat stronger associations among minority employees. These findings suggest the importance of employees’ lived experiences in meaningfully shifting organizational climates. The study contributes to research on diversity approaches by simultaneously considering the impact of formal and perceived policies and highlighting the policy-experienced gap, which reflects cross-level differences between organizational policy signals and employees’ interpretations of them. Keywords: diversity approach, inclusive climate, cross-level, minority/ majority, Intended-Actual-Experienced framework
Study research question
Collection provenance
  • External data
Collection methods
  • Questionaire
Personal data
No
External Source
Source description
File formats
Data types
  • Structured
Languages
  • English
Coverage start
Coverage end
Spatial coverage
Collection period start
Collection period end

Variables

Unit
Unit description
Sample size
Sampling method
Hypothesis
Theory
Variable type
Variable name
Variable description
Discipline-specific operationalizations
Conflict of interest
None

Data packages

Publications

Documents

Filename
Description
Date

Ethics

Ethical assessment
Yes
Ethical committee
Ethics Committee of the Faculty of Social and Behavioural Sciences of Utrecht University