Project info
Work package
- Inclusion
- Synthesis
Sustainability threat
- External Shocks
Challenge
- Accommodating newcomers
Study info
Description of Study
How people cooperate to provide public goods is a major scientific question and crucial for addressing many societal problems. Most research on cooperation in public good provision studied situations in which the same members of a group interact repeatedly or situations in which these members interact only once. However, many public good problems are characterized by a changing composition of group members over time. How changing groups affect cooperation in public good provision is not well understood. To address this issue, we analyze a large dataset from an online public goods game comprising 1.5 million contribution decisions made by 135.000 players in 11.500 groups with 250.000 recorded changes in the composition of these groups. We find that changes in group composition negatively relate to cooperation in public good provision, mainly because newcomers contribute less than incumbents. During the process of moving from newcomer status to incumbent status, individuals increase their contribution to the public good.
Study research question
What is the relationship between changes in group composition and cooperation in terms of contributions to a public good? Can this relationship be attributed to the contributions of the newcomers, the incumbents, or both?
Collection provenance
- External data
Collection methods
- Observation
Personal data
No
External Source
Source description
The dataset as described in the linked source
File formats
- CSV
- STATA
Data types
- Structured
Languages
- English
Coverage start
Coverage end
Spatial coverage
Collection period start
—
Collection period end
—
Variables
Unit
Unit description
Sample size
Sampling method
Communities
Groups (islands) on Ikariam
+/- 11500
Entire population on five game servers
Individuals
players on one of five servers of Ikariam
+/- 135000
Entire population on five game servers
Hypothesis
Theory
Variable type
Variable name
Variable description
Dependent variable
Contribution to the public good
Percentage of one's resources/endowment contributed to the public good(s)
Independent variable
Number of newcomers
—
Independent variable
Being a newcomer or incumbent
—
Control variable
Group size
—
Control variable
Time period
—
Discipline-specific operationalizations
Conflict of interest
none
Data packages
Publications
Documents
Filename
Description
Date
Ethics
Ethical assessment
Yes
Ethical committee
The Faculty Ethical Review Board of the Faculty of Social and Behavioural Sciences at Utrecht University